Make My Cake

Restaurant $

121 St Nicholas Ave
New York, NY 10026 Harlem Rate and review
Is This Your Listing? Are you the owner of Make My Cake in New York City New York? Send us more details! Claim Your Business Or Contact Us


Make My Cake is a full-service retail and wholesale bakery specializing in scrumptious baked goods that boast both Southern flavor and Harlem inspiration. For the past 15 years, Make My Cake has offered their clientele heavenly desserts such as the homestyle butter cake, the New York Times' pick, Red Velvet Cake, Food Network favorite, German Chocolate Cake, and local best-seller, Sweet Potato Cheesecake.

2380 Adam Clayton Powell Blvd.
New York, NY 10030

121A St. Nicholas Avenue
New York, NY 10026

Upcoming Events

Frequently Asked Questions

Places You Should Consider

4.7  Full RatingFull RatingFull RatingFull RatingFull Rating (5)
25 W 51st St, New York City NY, 10019
Johnny Utah’s is an underground saloon carved out of a converted bank vault and features New York City’s only mechanical bull. The Bull, or as we like...
4.8  Full RatingFull RatingFull RatingFull RatingFull Rating (3)
231 East 9th Street, New York NY, 10003
We offer over 200 kinds of carefully selected sakes, various authentic tapas-style dishes, and homemade desserts. Sakagura was founded in 1996 and has...
4.6  Full RatingFull RatingFull RatingFull RatingHalf Rating (2)
69 W 23rd St, New York NY, 10010
Welcome to New York City's newest and exciting Irish Bar. Our downstairs bar is open daily from 11am until 4am and offers both bar and waitress service....

Get to know Make My Cake

Our baking journey began decades ago and is based on family recipes and the cultural heritage of service and excellence practiced by our beloved matriarch, Josephine Smith, affectionately called "Ma Smith".

Make My Cake Photos

People Connected

Is Make My Cake one of your Favorite Places?

Add to My Connections

Plug Updates

Say Something or Ask a Question about Make My Cake

Recommended Ratings & Reviews

11111 Restaurant Atmosphere
11111 Food
11111 Service
11111 Cleanliness
11111 Bang for your Buck
11111 The Crowd
11111 Parking & Accessibility
Rate & Review

Join My Community would like to send you latest updates